- I read (by which I mean listened to in the car) a book by the name of "Finding God Beyond Harvard: The Quest for Veritas" in which the author kept remarking that people weren't meant to be rejected.
- I got in a discussion with my wife concerning the condoning of good/bad things, marriage or the lack thereof being the example used, and if there was a point in trying to get people who still needed God to do things that God tells us to do, even though it isn't going to improve their standing before Him without Christ.
The first bullet point was a new thought to me that I started mulling over in my head, which started somewhat of a random thought free-fall for me. Being rejected is painful. If humans were originally designed by God to be in a perfect world, I would imagine a perfect world to be a pain free environment. This would mean that pain would be unnatural to us.1 It's hard to imagine pain being an unnatural phenomenon, considering how interlaced into our lives it is, but if you think about all pain is just the insertion into our lives something that's not meant to be there. For example, my body is not designed to be stabbed, hence being stabbed is painful. My hand was not designed to be placed on a heating lamp, hence I find char-broiling my skin uncomfortable. I could go all day giving examples, but you get the idea. I think one could also extend this idea to emotional pain. Humans aren't meant to be completely alone, hence the onset of loneliness. We aren't meant to be lied to, hence the feeling of betrayal when it happens.
This may seem like I'm getting off track, but bear with me for a bit. I believe that God doesn't arbitrarily decree laws just for the sake of decreeing laws (although He would have the right to, were it in His nature), and that those laws are there to help show us how we are designed to live. If this is true, then taking God's advice and following his law tends to lead towards us living in a way that keeps us from unnatural circumstances in our lives. If I am correct in correlating that which is unnatural to us with pain, then following God's law would tend to lead us away from pain.
Now, consider God's decree that two people who want to be physically intimate with one another should be married first. Now, what is marriage at it's essence? A lot of people will throw around words like "civil union", "environment for raising children", "sexual partners", and so on and so forth. Those are all things that marriage leads to, not what it is. I would say that marriage, in it's most basic terms, is two people promising to never reject each other.
Who knows you better than a person you live and are physically intimate with? If the person who knows you best, rejects you, what higher form of rejection can a person face? I think this must be at least one reason that God decreed the institution of marriage for these sorts of situations. Because the world is fallen, we live in a place now where rejection is common place. I think this must be at least one reason that God decreed the institution of marriage.2 Marriage allows you to enter into this joyous situation, but protects from the potential anguish. I think this is why divorce is such a tragedy, because the intense pain of rejection is only added to by the betrayal of a broken promise. What was supposed to be a good thing, was twisted towards evil.
Assuming all of this is correct, then the question of "Should you make an effort to convince someone to do one of God's laws (in this case getting married before entering into the aforementioned cohabitation situation)?" can be answered with, "Should you help that person avoid pain?" The answer to both of those questions is the same.3
1) Don't take this to mean that I'm saying that pain is evil. It's more of a symptom of it and the world we live in. This doesn't mean that we should avoid pain at all costs either. There are still things that are worthy to do in spite of the evil in yourself or that others might inflict on you.
2) Don't take this to mean that I think God wants everyone to get married. There's definitely much good that can be accomplished better in singleness.
3) Man, there's a lot of "Don't take this to mean..."s here. Don't take this to mean that ostracizing and excessive nagging someone to be more moral is the way I'm advocating here. I'm just saying that encouraged/defending the position is worthy if the situation arises and you have the proper relationship with the person. As was hinted at in the second bullet point, it's far better to point someone to Christ than it is to convince them to drop a single sin. Any of us dropping any number of sins will not do us any good without the redemptive power of Jesus.