Saturday, April 14, 2012

Cthulhu and the Fear of God





Cthulhu!
Cthulhu

                Last time, I mentioned looking for truth in places not abundantly overflowing with it.  This time, I'm going to move from the realm of eastern philosophy and jump over to the oft disparaged-as-being-devoid-of-substance realm of dark stories.  So what spiritual truth could we get from Cthulhu, who tends to be more associated with...those less burdened with religious concerns? First, some background.

                Cthulhu is a fictional being created by H.P. Lovecraft.  He is an enormous hideous inter-dimensional alien  that is zillions of years old, the very sight of which kills people for the sheer horror.  Lovecraft, a raging atheist, often wrote about such beings of such unimaginable power, the very knowledge of which drove people insane.  They were just too great for man to fully comprehend them.  The protagonists of the Cthulhu story  in/directly encounter Cthulhu, and attempt to escape him.  They do, but are gradually driven insane by what they know to be true: the insignificance of man before this being, and the utter futility of resisting such a being. This is generally the overarching theme of most of Lovecraft's work (At least from what I've read, which, admittedly, would not qualify as most, but I've seen others say this).  His character's shook their fist at these incomprehensibly ancient and power beings, for that's all they can do, shake their fist and die.  I think it's intriguing stuff.1

                Here is my thought o' the day.  I think Lovecraft, despite his atheism, had a proper view of his position before God.2  I mean, think about what God is for a moment.  God is omnipotent, omniscient, and sovereign.  Resisting God is utterly out of the question, for He is so far beyond us.  We can't fully comprehend the eternity He encompasses.  People died in the Bible from simply looking directly at God. You can't run from Him, or even hide your thoughts from Him.  God is scary. 

                When most Christians talk about the "fear of God" they generally take it in the direction that we should just be reverent of Him, and I'm not going to disagree with that; we should.  But I think, in a sense, we should be afraid of God.  If you aren't at all, I don't think you really have a proper understanding of who God is.  He could smite us all in an instant and we could do nothing about it.  And what makes this worse, is that He is a perfectly just God, and we are far from a perfect people.  We daily, hourly even, offend and rebel against God and His law.  We all lie, steal, cheat, hate, lust, harm others, ect.  And God not only has the ability to destroy us for these things, but also a reason, because we deserve to be destroyed.

                At this point, it sounds like we ought to be quaking in the corner in abject terror.  And I, personally, don't think that that is an inappropriate action.  Thankfully, our God is also merciful and provided for us an escape from His all encompassing wrath and judgment, in the form of Jesus and His death and resurrection on the cross.  Thus, what was once a thing of unimaginable terror, for the Christian, has become a thing of unimaginable joy and thanksgiving because this righteous being of unfathomable power has shown us mercy from the fate we deserved. 

                I've heard the accusation many a time that Christianity is an emotional crutch from the harshness of the "real world."  It seems to me that it is the other way around.  Atheism seems more to be an emotional crutch from the reality of such an irresistible and just being.  Rather than coming to terms with Him and that we all will face judgement from Him, it is easier to just deny He exists in the first place.  That way, we can go about our little lives doing whatever we want, and comfort ourselves with the notion that it doesn't really matter, and we won't have to account for ourselves in the end.  Unfortunately, though, the men that ran from Cthulhu, though they escaped for a time, were eventually driven to despair by the knowledge they were trying to suppress, for they knew that there was no escape.  Apart from Christ, there is none.

                Now, if you want a more thorough, deeper, more insightful, and just plain better discussion on the general topic of this post (albeit with less inter-dimensional giant tentacled sea monsters from space),  go read Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God by Jonathan Edwards, which is excellent and I highly recommend you go read it.  Despite what the general populace tends to think, this sermon is more on God's mercy than His wrath.  You just need the latter to fully appreciate the former, and Edwards realizes that.

1)   In case your interest has been peaked, you can read "The Call of Cthulhu" for free on the interwebs.  

2)  On the off chance that someone actually reads this, and has read Lovecraft, don't take this to mean that I think he had a completely proper understanding of God (or at all for that matter).  I am only referring to this one particular aspect of his god-like beings that resembles the real God, an aspect that most atheists avoid and most Christians ignore.  Lovecraft's "great old ones" were merciless and uncaring, which is not how God is, thankfully.  If you're a Christian, you must see how an atheist would erroneously see God like this, for they can feel asked to do what they don't want to (follow God's law), or else be smote by Him.  A kind of happiness/destruction vs servitude/being saved. Though understandable, it is a self deception.  Since God made us, there is no fulfillment/happiness/self-actualization apart from Him, and any expectation of such things apart from Him is hopeless.  As they say, you must lose yourself in order to find yourself. 

Additional, I don't know if Lovecraft meant these beings to be analogies for God, but, even if he didn't, my point is still valid.


Wednesday, April 11, 2012

Glimmers of Truth


                I think that every religion/philosophy has an aspect of truth to it.  Now I know that this sounds a bit universalist of me, but before you set up some stakes and grab some rope and torches, hear me out and consider these two points:

1)            Humanity is unable to come up with something truly original.  We can modify things, ignore things, so on and so forth, but nothing is completely beyond human experience, or we would be unable to conceive of it.  Consider Cthulhu, the winged, octopus-faced, giant, green humanoid from beyond time and space. Now, there is nothing in existence with this certain combination of qualities, but we are familiar with these individual qualities.  We've just patch-worked together things we are familiar with to make something "new".  Consider any sci-fi media; all the aliens are the same way (insectoid qualities seem to be popular with many of them, since insects are so different from us). 

                What does this mean?  That even the most bold faced outlandish lie has an element of truth in it.  Consider this lie: My plant's leaves are blue.  Although my plant's leaves are green, and don't have a trace of blue on them, there are still elements of truth to this.  I took the true concepts or plants and blueness and combined them to make an untrue statement.  We know there was some truth in that statement just by the simple fact that it was comprehensible.    For example, here is a statement completely devoid of any truth a human has experienced: clabu zerubala glivenwah.  See that statement has no truth in it (that has been experienced by humans), and thus, has no meaning.  So, to put it another way, all lies are just a perversion of the truth, just as all evil is a perversion of good.  Now, keep this in mind as we move on, before I get off on a tangent about evil not being its own thing.

2)            Assuming Christianity is true (it is), Humanity is descended entirely from Adam and Eve.  They were knowledgeable about the one true God and had a proper worldview.  It must have been quite some time before there were people who could get His qualities all confused to the point where they were thinking of a different god, especially when we consider that the human race bottle necked with Noah and his immediate family, who definitely knew about the true God. 

                If both of these are true, then it leads to follow that all religions/philosophies are a perversion of Christianity, and thus must touch base with some ideas that are true (Christian) in order to be comprehensible to humans.  Thus, any practice or claim by any religion that doesn't contradict the Bible might be worth considering. 

                For example, what about the Buddhist propensity for meditation? I tend to hear about it somewhat frequently, either because I've studied a fair amount of martial arts, which tend to encourage the practice, and the people here in the states seem somewhat enamored with eastern mysticism as of late.  I've done some reading on the subject, and there does seem to be evidence of mental and physical benefits from it.  Now, I know many Christians tend to cringe at the mention of meditation, and pass it off as eastern non-sense, but the Bible does mention it.  "I will meditate on your precepts and fix my eyes on your ways." (Psalms 119:15)  Most, it seems, replace meditate with "think about", but what if we took it a step beyond that?  I don't think the Buddhist meditations stuff sounds so bad if you drop the "oneness with the universe" stuff.  What if we did find a quiet place to sit somewhere in God's creation, spend some time emptying our minds, and, instead of stopping there, then go on to meditate on God and His ways?  That doesn't sound so bad to me.  In fact, what if that is a good thing that we've forgotten about, because the idea seems foreign to us? 

                Now, I haven't reached a point where I would say that we all need to be doing this, but it seems like something at least worthy of some consideration. 

Sunday, March 11, 2012

Origin of the Universe

   Alright, in this post, in an attempt to do away with the idea that belief in God is fanciful or for the uneducated, I'm going to endeavor to prove God using reason and a bit of science.  I shall do this by listing off every possible theory of the origin of the universe that I can think of and deal with the likely-hood of each.  Here are all the theories of the origin of the material universe that I know about:
  1. The material universe is eternal and has always existed.
  2. The material universe was created by itself.
  3. The material universe was created by nothing.
  4. The material universe was created by another material universe.
  5. The material universe doesn't actually exist.
  6. A non-material entity created the material universe.
  7. Some other mystery reason we have no knowledge of yet.
   Now, rather than acting as a sane person would and address each of these in a completely separate post, I shall now attempt to tackle them all right now, one after the other:

1)   The material universe is eternal.
   Proponents of this theory generally argue that matter and energy is eternal, and that after an eternity, the universe just happened to float together into the form that we are familiar with today. My problem with this is that it violates the second law of thermodynamics which states that, "In any closed system, the entropy of the system will either remain constant or increase."  Entropy is the moving from a state of order to a state of disorder or thermodynamic equilibrium.  The entire material universe counts as a closed system, thus the entire universe is moving from a state of order to a state of disorder.  If you give the universe an infinite amount of time, then the universe will eventually reach a point where all energy has reached complete equilibrium and there is just hunks of matter floating in space.  This matter can't order itself into anything or even move without adding energy into the universe that wasn't there before, but that energy would have to come from somewhere outside the material universe, i.e. from some immaterial place, but that will be discussed at point 6.  

    This leads us to two questions: If the universe is eternally old, how come it hasn't reached this state yet?  And how did it organize itself to begin with, without having some outside source adding energy to perform the work of organizing it? 

    The answers are self apparent.  The universe should be dead by now, and it couldn't have brought forth life on its own.  Animate material objects, i.e. life can't maintain everything eternally, because we are not systems in equilibrium (or else we wouldn't be able to do work, such as breathing), and we require additional energy to be added to our systems, i.e. food, or else we start heading towards a state of energy equilibrium, i.e. we die and decompose.

2)   The universe created itself.
   For the universe to have created itself, it would need to simultaneously exist and not exist at the same time in the same sense.  It needs to exist to create something, and it needs to not exist to be created.  That breaks the law of non-contradiction, and is thus illogical.

3)   The universe spontaneously generated out of nothingness.
   Unfortunately, this obviously ridiculous idea is seriously believed by some.  I was watching a documentary on the origin of the universe and they had a bunch of big wig scientists trying to explain the origin of the universe by using the big bang.  According to them, and I kid you not, it is really easy to believe in if you simply accept the idea that something can come from nothing.  It's true.  Look up " How the Universe Works" and watch the first episode if you don't believe me.  It's on Netflix.  Apparently nothing, for no reason, a destructive explosion created everything.  And they have the audacity to say the idea of God is silly.

   For the sake of being thorough and trying to represent things accurately, not every proponent of the big bang believes it banged from nothing.  Some say that all matter was condensed into a tiny ball and exploded at some point for some reason.  Of course, one has to ask where the tiny ball of matter came from.  Some say it was eternal, but then we must ask why it didn't explode an eternity ago and we end up in the inevitable state of theory 1.  Some say all the matter was pulled in by a black hole, and then exploded once it gathered too much, but then we have to ask "Where did the black hole and the matter come from?"  The black hole is not there now, because the universe is expanding now, meaning everything is floating away from each other.  How come this hasn't happened an eternity ago?  You've essentially ended up with the same problems again that we had with theory 1, unless you take the next theory...

4)   This universe came from some other material universe.
   This material universe came from another material universe.  This theory takes a few different mutations.  Some say that this universe was made from the next one over.  This just delays the question and we have to ask where that universe came from.  You basically end up with an infinite regression.  You always need a universe that creates a universe that ultimately creates another universe.  Since this progression is supposed to be eternal, if you even have 1 universe that doesn't create another universe, then the cycle is forever broken, and impossible.  Why impossible?  For the same reason other changing things are impossible:  Why didn't this one non-creative universe happen an eternity ago?

   Going with the line of thinking in the previous paragraph, I've heard someone propose the idea of the universe being in a cycle, wherein it explodes, eventually gets sucked back in, and explodes again, starting all over, creating an infinite cycle.  Besides having a similar problem as the last situation (depending on something chaotic, an explosion, to behave in an orderly manner, and always explode in a way that creates circumstances conducive to another explosion eternally), this would also mean that the universe itself is a perpetual motion device.  As I learned after I had already started trying to make a perpetual motion device with magnets for an elementary school science fair, perpetual motion devices are impossible, as they violate the 1st law of thermodynamics, which says that a closed system (the universe) only has a certain amount of energy at it's expenditure.  At this point, the universe would be perpetually doing work without perpetually having energy fed into it.

5)   The material universe we experience is just an illusion.
   These people think that everything physical is just an illusion and don't actually exist.  If that's true, then those people, being physical, don't actually exist, so I don't need to deal with them.

6)   This universe was created by something immaterial. 
   The reasons all of these other theories failed is because they are relying on only physical things for the existence of the universe, and are thus subject to physics or they are just plain  illogical.  1 fails because it is unscientific.  2, 3, and 5 fail because they are illogical.  4 fails because it is unscientific and/or illogical.  So where does that leave us? What we need is some entity that is non-physical/material.  This immaterial thing has to be alive in order to do anything, not less create, giving us some non-physical being.  This non-physical being needs to be self existent and eternal, or else we end up with the problems in theories 2-5.  In order for this non-physical being to be eternal, it must then be unchanging, or else it would have changed an eternity ago into something chaotic.  This being also has to be one of a kind and more powerful than any other being, or else this being could have been overthrown and destroyed an eternity ago by some other being. 

   So, what we now have is a one of a kind being that is immaterial, eternal, unchanging, and all-powerful that created the material universe.  I personally like to use the word "God" to refer to an entity with these qualities, but if your impassioned hatred of anything that sounds religious causes you to choke at the word God, then I'll allow you to use some other word, such as "Ultimate Being" or "Creator" or "The Supreme Extraterrestrial."

   Unlike all the other theories, there is nothing about this theory that is illogical or breaks any scientific laws.  It is thus the only reasonable position to take. 

7)  The universe was created by the whatchamacallits leveraging the thingamajigs through the use of the doohickey. (i.e. the mystery reason we have no knowledge of yet.)
    Now, I throw this in there, not because it is a theory for the origin of the universe, but because there are those of us who the idea of a immaterial, eternal, unchanging, and omnipotent being is really frightening, because of the consequences of such an idea.  Thus, they fall back on the concept of, "Perhaps there's something else out there we haven't considered, or some extraneous circumstance we've never seen that proves number 6 untrue." 

   It is at this point that I'd like to bring up a principle widely attributed to the Franciscan monk, philosopher, and physicist, William of Ockham.  The idea of Ockham's Razor can be summarized as, "other things being equal, a simpler explanation is better than a more complex one."  Bertrand Russel put it a different way by saying, "Whenever possible, substitute constructions out of known entities for inferences to unknown entities."  What this is saying is that it is generally best to go with the explanation that makes the least assumptions and relies on the least unknowns.  Thus, the problem with picking number 7 over 6 is that, while they both could be considered logical and consistent with reality, 7 completely relies on the unknown discounting what we do know.  The only reason anyone would go with 7 over 6 is for some self serving or emotional reason.



   There it is.  I personally go with option 6, and think any other reasonable person ought to as well. You will notice, that I based all of this on science and logic. Now, if you are one of those people who thinks they are above using such contrivances as reason and logic, then this argument will not be a compelling one.  I will admit that I can only consistently arrive at God using logic, and if you don't use logic, then I can't convince you.  Just be sure to tell everyone that the reason you don't believe in God is because you aren't willing to use logic.  I'm ok with that.


   Let me know in the comments (either here or facebook) if there was some lapse in my logical progression in here, or if there is a theory for the origin of the universe that I missed that doesn't fit in one of the above categories. 

Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Faith and Logic


                Should faith be logical?  Some would say that we should have faith despite "logic" and "science" or "facts."  This is the meaning that atheists have perpetuated, and some believers go along with it. 
                It says in scripture that, "For God is not a God of confusion but of peace." (1 Cor. 14:33).  I believe God to be a God of logic.  I'm fairly certain that anyone who confesses Christ can agree that God is a God of truth.  So tell me:  Is it then within God's nature for Him to want us to believe something contradictory of logic or truth?  I think not.
                So what is faith, then? I would say faith is not believing something despite facts, but rather acting in accordance to the things we know to be true.  At this point, faith is a sort of informed courage.  Here are some examples of what I mean:
  • ·         Someone who, knowing God is sovereign, strikes out and boldly does the word of God without stopping for fear of failure is someone who has great faith. 
  • ·         Someone who doesn't worry about circumstances, because they know God has a plan, has great faith. 
  • ·         Someone who is shaken by being accused of contradiction and nonsense by atheists, but, knowing God is truth, goes and finds answers to those attacks has great faith. 
  • ·         Someone who is accused of contradiction and nonsense, but is ok with that and doesn't care enough to figure it out is a fool that makes the rest of us look bad.
                My point is this:  Like all things in life, you should have a reason for your faith.  Christians ought to have a reputation for being reasonable (Which we are currently sorely lacking).  Rather than believing in God despite science and logic, we should instead learn to reason and how science points to God, rather than away from Him, so that we may (gently and respectfully) crush into oblivion any arguments against God people bring to us.  We are called to this by scripture, for it says in 1 Peter 3:
                13 Now who is there to harm you if you are zealous for what is good? 14  But even if you should suffer for righteousness' sake, you will be blessed. Have no fear of them, nor be troubled, 15 but in your hearts honor Christ the Lord as holy, always being prepared to make a defense to anyone who asks you for a reason for the hope that is in you; yet do it with gentleness and respect, 16  having a good conscience, so that, when you are slandered, those who revile your good behavior in Christ may be put to shame. 17 For it is better to suffer for doing good, if that should be God's will, than for doing evil.

Saturday, March 3, 2012

The Knowledge of God in Everything


                I mentioned last time that, since I was not convinced that God doesn't exist, for me to disbelieve a story in the Bible, you'd need to convince me it wasn't in God's nature.  This was a sort of revelation for me that gave me new appreciation for Psalm 19.  Why stop at Biblical accounts?  Can that line of thinking not be applied to everything?
 
                If God is sovereign (He is), then nothing happens without Him allowing it to happen, or without Him directly making it happen.  Also, God does not do anything contrary to His own divine nature.  We could apply this to everything, not just, "Did Noah's Ark happen?", but also, "In 1492, did Columbus sail the ocean blue?"  and, "What is the composition of atoms?" and anything else you can think of.
 
                Let's say, hypothetically, that you had a perfect knowledge of God's nature.  Could you not derive all truth from that knowledge?  If there is something that is contrary to God's nature to allow to exist, then it wouldn't exist.  If we had perfect knowledge of God, we'd know how He composed the universe, whether a historical event came to pass, and indeed what will come to pass. 
 
                But, as Captain Obvious would point out, we do not have a perfect knowledge of the nature of God.  So instead, we have to learn science, math, history, ect. and look at how things are and what does and did happen.  But all of these things just go to show us what is in God's nature to allow to exist, thus all things serve to tell us of God.  By studying anything we are in fact studying God and His nature.  Really, all science, history, math, philosophy, ect. is just a subdivision of theology. 
 
                As it says in Psalm 19: The heavens declare the glory of God and the sky above proclaims His handiwork.  Day to day pours out speech, and night to night reveals knowledge.

Friday, March 2, 2012

Miraculous Logic

I've noticed a strange thing.  Materialists seem to commonly, when in debate, ask the Christian to explain how something told about in the Bible happened naturally.  If  the Christian responds with anything involving the supernatural, they are quickly cut off with a scoff and told that he/she doesn't believe in the supernatural, and that is all fairy-tales, and miracles are ridiculous, and so on and so forth.  When the Christian stumbles around with this trying to explain how it could have happened naturally, the materialist notices the lack of sound scientific evidence (not that there is none, but many Christians aren't sufficiently knowledgeable of the science involved), and the materialist feels quite superior.  Now, my non-existent readers, do you see what's strange with this scenario?  Why should the Christian have to defend a Biblical account, that presupposes God and the supernatural, without using God or the supernatural in the explanation?  If God doesn't exist, then the story is on the outset untrue.  If God does exist, then it's perfectly possible, even if no naturalistic explanation is found, because God can preform supernatural acts.

Allow me to illustrate with a personal example.  I was asked how the story of Noah's Ark was possible.  I was then thrown a large list of facts about how the amount of food required and the waste produced would overflow the ark, how it was impossible to store all these animals without disease running rampant, how there definitely wouldn't be enough genetic diversity in the animals that did survive, and so on and so forth.  Being that my knowledge of the biological sciences is somewhat limited, I was unable to think of a naturalistic explanation (even though I suspect there is one, as God seems to delight in solving many things without breaking the patterns of nature), and so I responded that God might have just made the whole thing work out miraculously.  This explanation was met with disdain, declared unsatisfactory, and ignored.  But why?  If one's philosophy has God in it, then it is possible to explain things as acts of God.  My imaginary readers, don't let them call you illogical in this.  There is nothing illogical about believing in miracles, when you maintain a philosophy that can explain their existence.  The reason they call you illogical, is because their philosophy of materialism doesn't allow for supernatural events.  Don't be taken in by their assumption that the supernatural is by necessity illogical (this will probably be a theme with these for awhile, but I will continue this line of thought another day).

Before we can ask, "Did Noah's Ark really happen?" (or any other question for that matter) we must first ask, "Does God exist?"  If the answer is "yes" then, since God is sovereign and not bound by the natural, the next question to ask is, "Is it within God's nature to do/allow this to happen?"  If it is within God's nature, then it happened.  If not, it didn't.  If the answer to God's existence is "no," then we have to ask how anything can happen, not just Noah's Ark.  The question of God's existence is the most fundamental question, upon the answer of which all the rest of our philosophy stands on. 

Now, this doesn't mean we shouldn't think how God might have managed Noah's Ark, but it isn't the necessity that many people seem to think it is.  The only reason to engage in a debate like that is because you find it personally enjoyable.  If you are trying to prove Noah's Ark, you should instead spend your time proving God.

I'll cut it off here before I start down one of the other lines of thought brought up here.  So, the application we should all take from this, is this:  It is not illogical to explain something with miracles, if your philosophy's basic ideas support them (i.e. says "Yes" to the God question).  Don't let anyone call you illogical for believing in miracles, if they can't establish that God's existence is illogical.

Thursday, March 1, 2012

Hypocracy

I've generally disapproved of blogs in the past.  I used to think the blog phenomenon was summed up aptly in this statement: "Never before have so many, with so little to say, said so much, to so few people." In fact, I still think that is mostly true.  I seriously doubt there is anyone out there that will read this (besides my lovely wife, who encouraged me to embark on this endeavor).

I can hear you ask, my non-existent readers, "Why write a blog then, if you are so convinced that you are ranting out loud on the internet to no one?"  That's a good question.  There's two reasons:

1) Personal Sanctification
I hope, that in writing this and feeling a need to keep up with it, I will be motivated to think deep and penetrating thoughts into the great truths of life.  By writing these thought here, I am forced to think through them coherently enough to write them out, and likewise they are recorded for my own personal benefit, so that I can remember all these great thoughts I have.

2) Positive Influence
My second reason involves the extremely unlikely scenario where someone actually reads this blog.  Firstly, I really enjoy theological and philosophical debate, yet I don't find it often.  Perhaps, this will serve as a forum for such beneficial discourse.  Secondly, it is not completely outside the realm of possibility that God, in His supreme sovereignty, will use me (and creation of this blog) for His glory, and this might be a vessel through which I positively influence the world for that purpose.

(There's other reasons.  I might one day start writing about computer security for the benefit of myself and others.  Then, once I have a reputation for being brilliant, I can start up the Internet Inquisition, which will be a repository for knowledge and truth, both theological and technological, that will be a shining beacon in the abyss that is the internet. And others like me shall gather there and bring forth a great reformation, in art, science, and philosophy.  But I'm way too embarrassed to admit any of these ideas floating around my head, and I wouldn't admit to the internet something like that on something as public as this.)

So yes.  There you go.  That is about as much personal information you're likely to get out of me ever again on the internet like this.  This isn't going to be me writing about my day, or my feelings, or anything that personal.  I have a moleskine for that stuff (again, at the encouragement of my wife).  Nope, just straight up philosophizing form here on out.  Prepare your non-existent selves.

Soli Deo Gloria.