Showing posts with label God's existence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label God's existence. Show all posts

Sunday, March 11, 2012

Origin of the Universe

   Alright, in this post, in an attempt to do away with the idea that belief in God is fanciful or for the uneducated, I'm going to endeavor to prove God using reason and a bit of science.  I shall do this by listing off every possible theory of the origin of the universe that I can think of and deal with the likely-hood of each.  Here are all the theories of the origin of the material universe that I know about:
  1. The material universe is eternal and has always existed.
  2. The material universe was created by itself.
  3. The material universe was created by nothing.
  4. The material universe was created by another material universe.
  5. The material universe doesn't actually exist.
  6. A non-material entity created the material universe.
  7. Some other mystery reason we have no knowledge of yet.
   Now, rather than acting as a sane person would and address each of these in a completely separate post, I shall now attempt to tackle them all right now, one after the other:

1)   The material universe is eternal.
   Proponents of this theory generally argue that matter and energy is eternal, and that after an eternity, the universe just happened to float together into the form that we are familiar with today. My problem with this is that it violates the second law of thermodynamics which states that, "In any closed system, the entropy of the system will either remain constant or increase."  Entropy is the moving from a state of order to a state of disorder or thermodynamic equilibrium.  The entire material universe counts as a closed system, thus the entire universe is moving from a state of order to a state of disorder.  If you give the universe an infinite amount of time, then the universe will eventually reach a point where all energy has reached complete equilibrium and there is just hunks of matter floating in space.  This matter can't order itself into anything or even move without adding energy into the universe that wasn't there before, but that energy would have to come from somewhere outside the material universe, i.e. from some immaterial place, but that will be discussed at point 6.  

    This leads us to two questions: If the universe is eternally old, how come it hasn't reached this state yet?  And how did it organize itself to begin with, without having some outside source adding energy to perform the work of organizing it? 

    The answers are self apparent.  The universe should be dead by now, and it couldn't have brought forth life on its own.  Animate material objects, i.e. life can't maintain everything eternally, because we are not systems in equilibrium (or else we wouldn't be able to do work, such as breathing), and we require additional energy to be added to our systems, i.e. food, or else we start heading towards a state of energy equilibrium, i.e. we die and decompose.

2)   The universe created itself.
   For the universe to have created itself, it would need to simultaneously exist and not exist at the same time in the same sense.  It needs to exist to create something, and it needs to not exist to be created.  That breaks the law of non-contradiction, and is thus illogical.

3)   The universe spontaneously generated out of nothingness.
   Unfortunately, this obviously ridiculous idea is seriously believed by some.  I was watching a documentary on the origin of the universe and they had a bunch of big wig scientists trying to explain the origin of the universe by using the big bang.  According to them, and I kid you not, it is really easy to believe in if you simply accept the idea that something can come from nothing.  It's true.  Look up " How the Universe Works" and watch the first episode if you don't believe me.  It's on Netflix.  Apparently nothing, for no reason, a destructive explosion created everything.  And they have the audacity to say the idea of God is silly.

   For the sake of being thorough and trying to represent things accurately, not every proponent of the big bang believes it banged from nothing.  Some say that all matter was condensed into a tiny ball and exploded at some point for some reason.  Of course, one has to ask where the tiny ball of matter came from.  Some say it was eternal, but then we must ask why it didn't explode an eternity ago and we end up in the inevitable state of theory 1.  Some say all the matter was pulled in by a black hole, and then exploded once it gathered too much, but then we have to ask "Where did the black hole and the matter come from?"  The black hole is not there now, because the universe is expanding now, meaning everything is floating away from each other.  How come this hasn't happened an eternity ago?  You've essentially ended up with the same problems again that we had with theory 1, unless you take the next theory...

4)   This universe came from some other material universe.
   This material universe came from another material universe.  This theory takes a few different mutations.  Some say that this universe was made from the next one over.  This just delays the question and we have to ask where that universe came from.  You basically end up with an infinite regression.  You always need a universe that creates a universe that ultimately creates another universe.  Since this progression is supposed to be eternal, if you even have 1 universe that doesn't create another universe, then the cycle is forever broken, and impossible.  Why impossible?  For the same reason other changing things are impossible:  Why didn't this one non-creative universe happen an eternity ago?

   Going with the line of thinking in the previous paragraph, I've heard someone propose the idea of the universe being in a cycle, wherein it explodes, eventually gets sucked back in, and explodes again, starting all over, creating an infinite cycle.  Besides having a similar problem as the last situation (depending on something chaotic, an explosion, to behave in an orderly manner, and always explode in a way that creates circumstances conducive to another explosion eternally), this would also mean that the universe itself is a perpetual motion device.  As I learned after I had already started trying to make a perpetual motion device with magnets for an elementary school science fair, perpetual motion devices are impossible, as they violate the 1st law of thermodynamics, which says that a closed system (the universe) only has a certain amount of energy at it's expenditure.  At this point, the universe would be perpetually doing work without perpetually having energy fed into it.

5)   The material universe we experience is just an illusion.
   These people think that everything physical is just an illusion and don't actually exist.  If that's true, then those people, being physical, don't actually exist, so I don't need to deal with them.

6)   This universe was created by something immaterial. 
   The reasons all of these other theories failed is because they are relying on only physical things for the existence of the universe, and are thus subject to physics or they are just plain  illogical.  1 fails because it is unscientific.  2, 3, and 5 fail because they are illogical.  4 fails because it is unscientific and/or illogical.  So where does that leave us? What we need is some entity that is non-physical/material.  This immaterial thing has to be alive in order to do anything, not less create, giving us some non-physical being.  This non-physical being needs to be self existent and eternal, or else we end up with the problems in theories 2-5.  In order for this non-physical being to be eternal, it must then be unchanging, or else it would have changed an eternity ago into something chaotic.  This being also has to be one of a kind and more powerful than any other being, or else this being could have been overthrown and destroyed an eternity ago by some other being. 

   So, what we now have is a one of a kind being that is immaterial, eternal, unchanging, and all-powerful that created the material universe.  I personally like to use the word "God" to refer to an entity with these qualities, but if your impassioned hatred of anything that sounds religious causes you to choke at the word God, then I'll allow you to use some other word, such as "Ultimate Being" or "Creator" or "The Supreme Extraterrestrial."

   Unlike all the other theories, there is nothing about this theory that is illogical or breaks any scientific laws.  It is thus the only reasonable position to take. 

7)  The universe was created by the whatchamacallits leveraging the thingamajigs through the use of the doohickey. (i.e. the mystery reason we have no knowledge of yet.)
    Now, I throw this in there, not because it is a theory for the origin of the universe, but because there are those of us who the idea of a immaterial, eternal, unchanging, and omnipotent being is really frightening, because of the consequences of such an idea.  Thus, they fall back on the concept of, "Perhaps there's something else out there we haven't considered, or some extraneous circumstance we've never seen that proves number 6 untrue." 

   It is at this point that I'd like to bring up a principle widely attributed to the Franciscan monk, philosopher, and physicist, William of Ockham.  The idea of Ockham's Razor can be summarized as, "other things being equal, a simpler explanation is better than a more complex one."  Bertrand Russel put it a different way by saying, "Whenever possible, substitute constructions out of known entities for inferences to unknown entities."  What this is saying is that it is generally best to go with the explanation that makes the least assumptions and relies on the least unknowns.  Thus, the problem with picking number 7 over 6 is that, while they both could be considered logical and consistent with reality, 7 completely relies on the unknown discounting what we do know.  The only reason anyone would go with 7 over 6 is for some self serving or emotional reason.



   There it is.  I personally go with option 6, and think any other reasonable person ought to as well. You will notice, that I based all of this on science and logic. Now, if you are one of those people who thinks they are above using such contrivances as reason and logic, then this argument will not be a compelling one.  I will admit that I can only consistently arrive at God using logic, and if you don't use logic, then I can't convince you.  Just be sure to tell everyone that the reason you don't believe in God is because you aren't willing to use logic.  I'm ok with that.


   Let me know in the comments (either here or facebook) if there was some lapse in my logical progression in here, or if there is a theory for the origin of the universe that I missed that doesn't fit in one of the above categories.